Report: Progressives seeking censure of Sinema over voting record

U.S. Sen. Kyrsten Sinema at an Arizona Chamber of Commerce and Industry event in May 2019. Photo by Gage Skidmore | Flickr/CC BY-SA 2.0

Progressives in Arizona want to formally censure U.S. Sen. Kyrsten Sinema for failing to support the party platform and siding with President Donald Trump too often.

To do so, the Progressive Caucus of the Arizona Democratic Party will introduce a resolution at this Saturday’s state party committee meeting. The resolution, which was first reported by ABC15, focuses specifically on her vote to confirm William Barr as U.S. attorney general and her failure to support the “Save the Internet Act,” which seeks to preserve the net neutrality protections created under President Barack Obama.

Sinema was one of only three Democrats who voted to confirm Barr, and she was one of only two Democrats not to co-sponsor the net neutrality legislation

ABC15 reported that the potential censure would come from the Arizona Democratic Party. However, a different version of the motion to censure provided to Arizona Mirror (and hosted on the state party’s website) specifies that the censure is being issued only by the Progressive Caucus, not the full Arizona Democratic Party.

“We love her, as we love all Democrats, but we want her to vote like a Democrat rather than supporting Trump half the time,” Dan O’Neil, a leader in the Progressive Caucus, told ABC15. 

That’s not hyperbole, either: According to vote-tracking by political analysis site FiveThirtyEight, Sinema has sided with Trump nearly 55% of the time since he became president. (That figure doesn’t tell the whole story, however, as Sinema has sided with Trump only 19% of the time since being elected to the Senate. Still, even that lower figure places her behind only West Virginia’s Joe Manchin among Democratic senators voting with Trump.)

Earlier this year, members of the Progressive Democrats for America protested Sinema at an Arizona Democratic Party dinner. While Sinema spoke to the crowd, they held up signs that said “Vote like a Democrat.”

Sinema began her political career as an unabashed left-winger, running for the Legislature Phoenix City Council under the Green Party banner before becoming a Democrat and winning her first legislative race in 2004. From there, she gradually migrated toward the center, and after she was first elected to the U.S. House of Representatives in 2012, she established herself as one of the most moderate Democrats in the chamber.

That trend has not only continued, but has become more pronounced, and many Democrats have become increasingly disenchanted with Sinema since she joined the Senate in January. She voted to confirm U.S. Attorney General William Barr, who has become one of congressional Democrats’ biggest nemeses. She opposed Democratic efforts to restore net neutrality rules. And she waffled on taking a position on the findings of special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election.

Sinema has also been targeted by outside interest groups for her stance on the net neutrality bill. In April, one group bought a billboard on Interstate 17 claiming Sinema was “corrupt” because she put the interests of telecom companies over her constituents.

If the Democratic Party approves a censure of Sinema, it won’t be the first time a political party here has taken aim at its most prominent U.S. senator. In 2014, the Arizona Republican Party censured U.S. Sen. John McCain for not being conservative enough. That censure called his voting record “disastrous and harmful” to both Arizona and the nation.

**This story was updated to include information on a second version of the motion to censure that comes only from the Progressive Caucus.**


  1. Good idea, Dems. Stir things up within the party and maybe Az can get an R back in that job! Work behind the scenes and not in the public forum!

  2. Democrats need to focus. 2020 may be the most important election for decades. Getting diverted to a symbolic vote to damage a Democratic senator who is popular with a large number of Arizonans and is not up for reelection until 2024 is self-destructive behavior. Win across the board in 2020 and Sinema will act accordingly. If not challenge her in 2024.

  3. There is no damage being done to Sinema by this censure. Perhaps you other commenters live in a community where she HAS opened an office or DOES respond to emails and phone calls. But down here in Pima County she doesn’t do any of those things, so how can she possibly represent us? Focusing on standing up for our principles and not always UNCONDITIONALLY supporting our electeds who think we work for them instead of the other way around is the kind of focus the party needs. Every time we DON’T hold their feet to the fire there is one more Independent saying “I’ll never vote Democrat, they don’t STAND for anything”. Well, some of us do stand for something, and there is no problem in saying so.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here