• Election 2020
    • Battle for the Ballot
  • Education
  • Immigration
  • Criminal Justice & Policing
  • Politics
  • Law & Government
  • Redistricting
  • Benson’s Corner
Search
Saturday, January 16, 2021
  • Home
  • Commentary
  • About
  • Newsletter
  • A to Z | The Blog
  • Contact
  • Donate
The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues. Arizona Mirror

Insightful. Investigative. Independent.

The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues.
  • Election 2020
    • Battle for the Ballot
  • Education
  • Immigration
  • Criminal Justice & Policing
  • Politics
  • Law & Government
  • Redistricting
  • Benson’s Corner
Donald Trump
President Donald Trump in a shadow at a February 2017 ceremony in North Charleston, S.C., recognizing the first Boeing 787-10 produced. Photo by City of North Charleston | Flickr
  • Capitol Hill

Democrats, fearing a self-pardon, unveil resolution to impeach Trump

By
Daniel Newhauser
-
January 8, 2021
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Email
Print

    WASHINGTON — Among the factors undergirding the new effort by House Democrats to impeach President Donald Trump again is a controversial legal theory that doing so could bar him from pardoning himself, according to those involved.

    The theory is among the many reasons — and there are many, as tempers still flare after a violent and destructive attack on the Capitol by Trump supporters on Wednesday — that more than 100 House Democrats have signed on to an effort to impeach Trump, confirmed two members of Congress and a congressional aide involved in the talks.

    That reasoning has only taken on more urgency as Trump has in recent weeks discussed issuing himself a pardon, according to The New York Times, which cited two unnamed sources with knowledge of Trump’s discussions.

    When asked about a Trump pardon on a call with reporters on Thursday, U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.), who is sponsoring the impeachment resolution, declined to address the issue specifically. She said instead that she is leading the effort because she thinks in the big picture, Trump is dangerous. 

    She said she tried to contact House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and urged the speaker to call her back and support the impeachment.

    “I do believe that we are facing an imminent threat from this president and that has to be the number one priority in pursuing this impeachment,” Omar told States Newsroom. “The sole goal right now is for there to be accountability for what transpired (Wednesday) and to protect our nation, our republic, from the dangerous actions of this president. And so, we know that we have a constitutional obligation to impeach.”

    Pelosi, for her part, said at a news conference Thursday that she wants the president removed from office by the 25th Amendment, and threatened that impeachment is an option if Vice President Mike Pence and the Cabinet fail to act. 

    Pence, meanwhile, reportedly opposes removing Trump from office using the 25th Amendment.

    The impeachment resolution, released Thursday, condemns Trump for trying to goad Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to overturn the state’s presidential election and also for inciting the violence that led to the Capitol riots Wednesday. 

    Many House Democrats signed on to cosponsor the resolution, including Arizonans Raul Grijalva and Ann Kirkpatrick; Florida’s Kathy Castor, Val Demings and Frederica Wilson; Nevada’s Steve Horsford; Tennessee’s Steve Cohen; Virginia’s Gerry Connolly; and Wisconsin’s Mark Pocan.

    Why impeachment?

    For Democrats, there are several potential victories to be had in an impeachment, one being that if Trump is successfully impeached, he could also be disqualified from occupying the role of president again.

    The other is the potential constraint on his ability to pardon himself for what Democrats and an increasing number of Republicans see as his role in encouraging Wednesday’s riots at the Capitol.

    The idea about the pardons is based on an expansive reading of the text in the Constitution that a president has broad pardon powers, “except in cases of impeachment.” Like so much else in the Trump years, the theory has not been tested. 

    Some scholars believe the wording simply precludes a president from ending impeachment proceedings with a self-pardon — or using a pardon to stop impeachment proceedings against other elected officials. 

    More recently, though, other scholars have interpreted the text to mean that a president could not pardon himself for the underlying alleged crimes for which the president is being impeached, thereby shielding him from criminal indictment after he leaves office.

    This may go some of the way toward explaining why members of Congress are pushing so hard with only 13 days to go in Trump’s term to impeach him, a process that could take longer than those 13 days.

    Jeffrey Tulis, a professor of government at the University of Texas, recently wrote extensively about the theory in The Atlantic, along with Corey Brettschneider, a Brown University political science professor.

    Tulis said in an interview Thursday that commencing an impeachment proceeding could add one arrow to the quiver of those who would field a legal challenge against a presidential self-pardon, if Trump does go that route. 

    No president has ever pardoned himself, and legal scholars are undecided whether it would be constitutional, but many say it would certainly be challenged.

    Tulis said he would like to see Congress, in any impeachment resolution, explicitly note that it is doing so at least in part to limit Trump’s pardon powers, because then the courts would be more likely to take up the question.

    “If Congress, in impeaching, also expresses its opinion of the limits of the pardon power, that would in fact weigh heavily on courts. They would actually care,” he said. “Just beginning this inquiry, and ideally voting on articles of impeachment whether or not he’s tried for them, would strengthen the argument that he can’t pardon himself.”

    However, other scholars don’t see it that way. 

    Brian Kalt, a law professor at the University of Michigan, said although he believes a president cannot pardon himself, he takes the constitutional language to mean only that a president cannot undo an impeachment through a pardon. 

    Far from stopping the president from pardoning himself, Kalt said, the introduction of an impeachment resolution could push Trump to pardon himself more quickly, before the House has time to vote to impeach.

    “It’s a recent development that people have tried to reinterpret that impeachment exception to the pardon power,” Kalt said in a Thursday interview. “It’s long settled and very clear that all that [language] means is that impeachment proceedings are separate from criminal proceedings, and pardons only reach criminal proceedings.”

    Still, Kalt said an impeachment could hold value even after Trump leaves office, because there is precedent for carrying on an impeachment trial even after an elected official’s term has ended. Trump could thus be disqualified even after he has fully finished his first term.

    • TAGS
    • Donald Trump
    • Ilhan Omar
    • impeachment
    • Nancy Pelosi
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Google+
    Email
    Print
      Daniel Newhauser
      Daniel Newhauser
      Daniel Newhauser is a freelance journalist based in Washington, D.C. His work has appeared in The Atlantic, The Daily Beast, National Journal, Politico, Roll Call, VICE News and several other publications. He can be found on Twitter @dnewhauser.

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      covid vaccine
      Capitol Hill

      Biden pledges massive vaccine uptick as states struggle with confusion over dosage numbers

      Capitol Hill

      More than 21,000 Guard members from 50 states headed to D.C., and numbers may grow

      Capitol Hill

      U.S. House votes to again impeach Trump, as a ‘clear and present danger’

      COVID-19 in Arizona

      BENSON’S CORNER

      Silence is complicity

      LATEST STORIES

      • Ducey wants savings from K-12 enrollment decline to help students who have fallen behind in pandemic
      • Biden pledges massive vaccine uptick as states struggle with confusion over dosage numbers
      • Ducey calls for $600 million in permanent income tax cuts
      • More than 21,000 Guard members from 50 states headed to D.C., and numbers may grow
      • GOP proposal would criminalize ‘intimidating’ police, first responders
      A Twitter List by Arizona Mirror
      X

      Republishing Guidelines ►

      ▪ You must give Arizona Mirror credit, including https://www.azmirror.com/ and author.

      ▪ If you publish online, include the links from the story, and a link to Arizona Mirror.

      ▪ Stories may be edited for in-house style or to shorten. More substantial changes should be noted as additional and conducted by your publication.

      ▪ You can publish our graphics and any photos that are credit to Arizona Mirror with the stories with which they originally appeared. For any other uses, you must seek permission from us at [email protected]

      ▪ If you share the story on social media, please mention ArizonaMirror on Twitter and azmirror on Facebook.

      ▪ Don't sell the story.

      ▪ Don’t sell ads against the story. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page with ads you’ve already sold.

      Democrats, fearing a self-pardon, unveil resolution to impeach Trump

      by Daniel Newhauser, Arizona Mirror
      January 8, 2021

      1

      Creative Commons License

      Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site.

      The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues.
      ABOUT US
      Amplifying the voices of Arizonans whose stories are unheard; shining a light on the relationships between people, power and policy; and holding public officials to account.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      • Home
      • Commentary
      • About
      • Newsletter
      • A to Z | The Blog
      • Contact
      • Donate
      © Arizona Mirror 2021
      Adjust Font Size
      MORE STORIES

      Ducey wants savings from K-12 enrollment decline to help students who...

      Education January 16, 2021
      covid vaccine

      Biden pledges massive vaccine uptick as states struggle with confusion over...

      Capitol Hill January 15, 2021
      Edit with Live CSS
      Save
      Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.