• Election 2020
    • Battle for the Ballot
  • Education
  • Immigration
  • Criminal Justice & Policing
  • Politics
  • Law & Government
  • Redistricting
  • Benson’s Corner
Search
Tuesday, January 19, 2021
  • Home
  • Commentary
  • About
  • Newsletter
  • A to Z | The Blog
  • Contact
  • Donate
The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues. Arizona Mirror

Insightful. Investigative. Independent.

The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues.
  • Election 2020
    • Battle for the Ballot
  • Education
  • Immigration
  • Criminal Justice & Policing
  • Politics
  • Law & Government
  • Redistricting
  • Benson’s Corner
Tyson workers have had plastic dividers separating them on the production line. Photo provided by Tyson Fresh Meats
  • Capitol Hill
  • COVID-19
  • Health
  • Law & Government
  • Politics

Workers’ COVID-19 lawsuits could be quashed under GOP push in Congress

By
Ariana Figueroa
-
December 17, 2020
Facebook
Twitter
Google+
Email
Print

    WASHINGTON — A wrongful death lawsuit filed in connection with a Tyson meat packing facility in Iowa alleged that managers secretly took bets on how many employees would get sick from COVID-19.

    Tyson fired seven managers at the Waterloo pork processing plant following an independent investigation into the betting allegations and a wave of national publicity.

    But labor advocates say that suit and others like it would have little chance of success in court if Republicans in Congress succeed in passing legislation that would shield businesses from pandemic-related lawsuits.

    Senate Republicans dropped their insistence that a liability provision be included in a bipartisan COVID-19 relief package that could pass Congress as soon as this weekend. 

    But union advocates worry that the measure could spring back to life next year, arguing that it would harm workers and undercut the incoming Biden administration’s plans to control the pandemic.

    If passed, a liability shield provision championed by a senior member of the Senate GOP would prevent workers and consumers from bringing lawsuits against employers who don’t take proper safety steps to limit exposure to the virus. 

    The AFL-CIO wrote in a Dec. 12 letter to senators that the provision by Texas Sen. John Cornyn would also prevent states from stepping in with their own enforcement of workplace standards to keep employees safe from coronavirus exposure.

    “The draft proposal specifically bars enforcement of state occupational health and safety standards,” wrote William Samuel, the director of government affairs at the AFL–CIO. “So states that have adopted strong OSHA standards to protect working people from the virus in the absence of federal action, such as Virginia and California, would be prevented from enforcing them.”

    The liability shield language is a redline issue for Republicans, who for months have argued that companies, hospitals, universities, local governments and other businesses need protection from customers and workers who could potentially flood them with COVID-19 related lawsuits. 

    Republicans say such shields are routine.

    “There is Democrats’ apparently strong opposition to enacting any kind of legal protections to aid the reopening—targeted, temporary liability reforms are a common feature of national emergencies or strange events,” Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) said during a floor speech on Dec. 11.

    Democrats and labor groups have pushed back, pointing out that the Cornyn provision creates a high bar for workers to prove an employer willfully endangered or exposed them to the virus. Cornyn introduced his bill in July, the Safe to Work Act, that would shield businesses from COVID 19-related lawsuits, and Republicans wanted to attach the Cornyn bill as a section in the latest relief package.

    Democrats say the liability fight is why relief has gotten held up to the end of the year.

    “At a time of such great crisis, there is one reason why America’s two major parties have not gotten together during the time of acute national emergency, and that is because the Republican leader has demanded a partisan poison pill, a sweeping corporate liability shield be included in any legislation, otherwise he won’t let it pass,” Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said on the Senate floor on Dec. 11.

    Cornyn’s bill prevents state and federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration agencies from enforcing workplace safety measures for two-and-a-half years, such as social distancing, required mask wearing and proper areas for handwashing. 

    That would mean that if the Biden administration wants to direct OSHA to implement COVID-19 standards or for the agency to conduct any enforcement, the provision would prevent that from happening for an extended period. And any discrimination cases on questions such as race, sex and disability that have to do with coronavirus would also be on hold for two-and-a-half years.

    The liability shield question has dogged emergency relief talks. A draft  of a proposal for emergency relief from a bipartisan group earlier this month would also establish a “nationwide gross negligence standard for COVID-19 exposure, medical malpractice, and workplace testing claims.” 

    Judy Conti, the government affairs director at the National Employment Law Project, said that a nationwide standard would require workers to have the highest proof of burden for “gross negligence.”

    “You would have to essentially prove that employers knew that what they were going to do would cause people to die, but they did it anyway,” Conti said. 

    The debate over liability comes as workers in places ranging from meatpacking plants in Pennsylvania to Amazon warehouses are filing suits against their employers for not following COVID-19 guidelines or providing proper protective equipment. 

    In Congress, the liability fight has caused so much controversy that the bipartisan group of senators split their COVID-19 relief package into two parts. One part included aid both parties agreed on, such as extensions of unemployment benefits, food assistance, a paycheck protection program, COVID-19 testing and vaccine distribution. 

    The other part was $160 billion in aid to state, local and tribal governments— strongly backed by Democrats—and the liability shield for companies that Republicans wanted. It now appears neither will make it into a final relief deal.

    • TAGS
    • AFL-CIO
    • Chuck Schumer
    • coronavirus
    • COVID-19
    • John Cornyn
    • Mitch McConnell
    • National Employment Law Project
    • Occupational Safety and Health Administration
    • OSHA
    • Safe to Work Act
    • Tyson
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Google+
    Email
    Print
      Ariana Figueroa
      Ariana Figueroa
      Ariana Figueroa is a reporter for States Newsroom's Washington bureau.

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Education

      Ducey wants savings from K-12 enrollment decline to help students who have fallen behind in pandemic

      covid vaccine
      Capitol Hill

      Biden pledges massive vaccine uptick as states struggle with confusion over dosage numbers

      Arizona

      Ducey calls for $600 million in permanent income tax cuts

      COVID-19 in Arizona

      BENSON’S CORNER

      Political courage this ain't

      LATEST STORIES

      • Tucson Diocese being sued for racketeering over alleged sex abuse
      • Violent extremists stand with Donald Trump — as do many of my Marine buddies
      • Ducey wants savings from K-12 enrollment decline to help students who have fallen behind in pandemic
      • Biden pledges massive vaccine uptick as states struggle with confusion over dosage numbers
      • Ducey calls for $600 million in permanent income tax cuts
      A Twitter List by Arizona Mirror
      X

      Republishing Guidelines ►

      ▪ You must give Arizona Mirror credit, including https://www.azmirror.com/ and author.

      ▪ If you publish online, include the links from the story, and a link to Arizona Mirror.

      ▪ Stories may be edited for in-house style or to shorten. More substantial changes should be noted as additional and conducted by your publication.

      ▪ You can publish our graphics and any photos that are credit to Arizona Mirror with the stories with which they originally appeared. For any other uses, you must seek permission from us at [email protected]

      ▪ If you share the story on social media, please mention ArizonaMirror on Twitter and azmirror on Facebook.

      ▪ Don't sell the story.

      ▪ Don’t sell ads against the story. Feel free, however, to publish it on a page with ads you’ve already sold.

      Workers’ COVID-19 lawsuits could be quashed under GOP push in Congress

      by Ariana Figueroa, Arizona Mirror
      December 17, 2020

      1

      Creative Commons License

      Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site.

      The Arizona Mirror is an independent, nonprofit news organization that is focused on connecting public policy with the people it affects and bringing a fresh perspective to coverage of the state’s biggest issues.
      ABOUT US
      Amplifying the voices of Arizonans whose stories are unheard; shining a light on the relationships between people, power and policy; and holding public officials to account.
      Contact us: [email protected]
      FOLLOW US
      • Home
      • Commentary
      • About
      • Newsletter
      • A to Z | The Blog
      • Contact
      • Donate
      © Arizona Mirror 2021
      Adjust Font Size
      MORE STORIES

      Tucson Diocese being sued for racketeering over alleged sex abuse

      Arizona January 19, 2021

      Violent extremists stand with Donald Trump — as do many of...

      Commentary January 19, 2021
      Edit with Live CSS
      Save
      Write CSS OR LESS and hit save. CTRL + SPACE for auto-complete.