Senate approves committee to study murders of Native American women




Rep. Jennifer Jermaine, D-Chandler, sponsored legislation to examine violence against Native women. Photo by Jerod MacDonald-Evoy | Arizona Mirror

A bill aimed at shining a light on cases of murdered and missing indigenous women and girls, often referred to as MMIWG cases, won unanimous approval in the Arizona Senate Thursday.

House Bill 2570, introduced by Rep. Jennifer Jermaine, D-Chandler, would create a committee to study murders of indigenous women and girls and would submit a detailed report later this year to the governor and state legislators.

The bill faces a final vote in the House of Representatives before it reaches Gov. Doug Ducey’s desk.

Jermaine sat in the back of the Senate as her colleagues voted on the bill, which is is similar to a measure passed last year in Washington which was partially inspired by a lawmaker’s viewing of the film Wind River, which focuses on a murder on the Wind River Indian Reservation in Wyoming.

“In her first session, she’s been a champion on this,” Sen. Sean Bowie, D-Phoenix, said of Jermaine before his vote.

If the bill becomes law, the committee will consist of chairpersons of the House of Representatives and the Senate’s Indigenous Peoples Caucus, the attorney general or a designee, the director of the Department of Public Safety or their designee, a sheriff and county attorney from each county, one tribal representative, one victim advocate, one tribal chief of police, one peace officer from a reservation, a social worker and others who work with Native American communities.

“We have a nationwide crisis of data,” Sen. Victoria Steele, D-Tucson, said during voting in the Senate. Steele sponsored identical legislation earlier this year, but the Senate never considered it.

An Arizona Mirror analysis of the sparse publicly available data found that more than 25 percent of murders involving idigenous women in Arizona go unsolved.


However, when it comes to reporting on Native deaths, there are major issues when it comes to the data.

As researchers with the Urban Indian Health Institute pointed out in a study last year, many agencies that report crime data to the FBI are not doing so properly. The Santa Fe Police Department told UIHI researchers last year that they could not separate Native women within its own data sets.

Additionally, race is generally not determined by the medical examiner’s office and is determined by whoever is issuing the death certificate.

It’s unclear what are the exact limitations of the data for Arizona, which is something Steele said she hopes will change after the study committee submits its findings.

All the current data is based on FBI crime data, which is voluntarily submitted by departments and has been found to have flaws, so it is unclear what the real numbers of unsolved MMIWG cases are in Arizona.

The Ak-Chin Tribal Police reported only a single homicide in the FBI records, and it remains unsolved. The Tohono O’odham Police reported 33 murders from 2006 to 2016 but solved only 2 of them, the data shows. The Fort Apache Police Agency reported 91 homicides from 2006 to 2016 and solved only one.

The bill also had a personal impact for one member of the Senate.

Sen. Jamescita Peshlakai, D-Window Rock, spoke passionately about an MMIWG case that was close to home.

Her niece, Amanda Dakota Webster, was killed in Kentucky late last year.

She was a resident of the small town of Cameron on the Navajo Reservation due east of the Grand Canyon.

She was a mother of three sons. Unlike many other MMIWG cases, her murderer was found.

Peshlakai, a member of the Navajo Nation, spoke about a Navajo tradition in regards to death when discussing her yes vote on the bill.

“When a person passes on, we don’t say their name anymore,” Peshlakai said, adding that families tend to move on, pack up their loved one’s belongings and go forward.

But Peshlakai said that tradition needs to change.

“We need to remember and say their names,” shesaid, holding back tears.

Jerod MacDonald-Evoy
Reporter Jerod MacDonald-Evoy joins the Arizona Mirror from the Arizona Republic, where he spent 4 years covering everything from dark money in politics to Catholic priest sexual abuse scandals. Jerod has also won awards for his documentary films which have covered issues such as religious tolerance and surveillance technology used by police. He brings strong watchdog sensibilities and creative storytelling skills to the Arizona Mirror.

1 COMMENT

  1. Catching the murderer doesn’t end the discrepancies in justice. County Attorney Montgomery spent millions of dollars to convict Jodi Arias for the brutal murder of Travis Alexander. In the same time period Annovedwin Begay-Barakzai was murdered by Dougles Ray George. Both murders took place in the east valley. Per the East Valley Tribune (June 15) Begay-Barakzai suffered broken ribs, lacerated liver, numerous stab wounds to face and chest. Her nude body was left next to an elementary school, something even Jodi didn’t do. For this horror Montgomery’s office saw fit to accept a plea deal of 15 years. For one victim (white male) Montgomery pulled out all the stops. For the other victim (indigenous female) get what you can and lets move on.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here